Hill grew up in Virginia Beach, Virginia. In 2003, she received her graduate degree from the Shakespeare Theatre's Academy for Classical Acting at George Washington University. A classically trained stage actor, Hill started performing in comedy after moving to Los Angeles and beginning to perform at the Upright Citizens Brigade Theatre.
She continues to perform at the UCB Theatre. In 2014, Hill began playing the role of Phe Phe Reed in the Hulu sitcom The Hotwives. In 2014, Hill was cast in the NBC comedy series Marry Me as a series regular, playing the role of Kay until the series' cancellation after one season.
