Scholey has lent her voice to radio dramas including All Passion Spent, A Harlot's Progress and Under Milk Wood. She was runner-up in the BBC Carleton Hobbs Radio Competition 2005. In 2011, she provided voice for Ginny Weasley in the video game version of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Part 2
Also for television, she played Diana Rivers in the 2006 BBC adaptation of Jane Eyre, Lucy Pfister in the recently improvised comedy series Family Tree for HBO, NBC, and BBC. She has also appeared in episodes of George Gently, EastEnders, Holby City, and Poirot.
Scholey has worked extensively on screen and in theatre. She appeared (July/Aug 2013) in the revival of Passion Play by Peter Nichols (at the Duke of York's Theatre) as the predatory younger woman, Kate. She also worked at The Royal National Theatre in their summer production of Antigone playing the role of Ismene. In June 2011 Scholey played Lady Anne, in Sam Mendes adaptation of Richard III with Kevin Spacey in the title role, at the Old Vic theatre in London and the Brooklyn Academy of Music in New York. The production opened to rave reviews. In 2010, Scholey played Hermia alongside Dame Judi Dench in A Midsummer Night's Dream at The Rose Theatre Kingston and later that year appeared as 'Julia' in Sheridan's "The Rivals", alongside Penelope Keith and Peter Bowles (of To the Manor Born) at the Haymarket Theatre in London. Both productions were directed by Sir Peter Hall.
